Understanding Passato Prossimo vs. Imperfetto with the Verb Essere

One of the common challenges for students learning Italian is knowing when to use the passato prossimo versus the imperfetto. This becomes especially tricky with the verb essere (to be), which can be expressed as è stato/a or era in the past. Both forms describe past actions, but they serve different purposes in conversation. Let’s explore how to use each correctly.

The passato prossimo tense is used to describe actions that happened at a specific point in time and are now completed. In the case of the verb essere, we use è stato (for masculine singular) or è stata (for feminine singular) to convey the idea of “it was” or “it has been.” This tense is often paired with time expressions like “yesterday,” “last week,” or a specific year.

La festa di compleanno è stata fantastica.

The birthday party was fantastic.

In this sentence, è stata highlights that the party was a complete event that occurred in the past and is now over. There’s a clear sense that this is a finished moment, remembered as a whole.

Imperfetto: Descriptions and Ongoing Actions

On the other hand, the imperfetto is used for descriptions, habitual actions, or ongoing states in the past. With the verb essere, we use era (it was) to describe situations or conditions that don’t refer to a specific point in time but instead provide context or background.

Il mare era tranquillo, e l’aria era fresca.

The sea was calm, and the air was fresh.

Here, era doesn’t refer to a specific event but rather paints a picture of the environment. It gives us the feeling of what the setting was like at that time.Write your text here...

Practical Examples

Il viaggio a Parigi è stato incredibile.

The trip to Paris was incredible.

This describes a specific, completed event: the trip is over, and the speaker is reflecting on the experience as a whole.

Le strade erano piene di turisti.

The streets were full of tourists.

Passato Prossimo

Imperfetto

This sets the scene by describing what the environment was like during the trip, without specifying a particular moment.

When to Use Each Tense

• Use the passato prossimo when you want to focus on what happened. It’s for events, actions, or experiences that are completed in the past.

• Use the imperfetto when you want to focus on what something was like or what used to happen. It’s more about the background, conditions, or habitual actions.

Do you want to improve your Italian? Book a lesson with me, and together we’ll reach your language goals!